Statement Calling for Constitutional Resistance to Obergefell v. Hodges
We are scholars and informed citizens deeply concerned by the edict of the Supreme Court of the United States in Obergefell v. Hodges
wherein the Court decreed, by the narrowest of margins, that every
state in the country must redefine marriage to include same-sex
relationships.

The Court’s majority opinion eschewed
reliance on the text, logic, structure, or original understanding of the
Constitution, as well as the Court’s own interpretative doctrines and
precedents, and supplied no compelling reasoning to show why it is
unjustified for the laws of the states to sustain marriage as it has
been understood for millennia as the union of husband and wife.
The opinion for the Court substituted for
traditional—and sound—methods of constitutional interpretation a new
and ill-defined jurisprudence of identity—one that abused the moral
concept of human dignity.
The four dissenting justices are right to reject the majority opinion in unsparing terms.