Judge Who Sided With Gay Couple over Christian B&B Owners Now Accepts Religious Rights
21 Jun 2014
The Supreme Court judge who ruled against a Christian couple who refused a room in their bed and breakfast established to a gay couple appears to have performed an about-face in her decision on the case.
Thought it is too late for these particular defendants,
Baroness Hale's recent comments claiming there should be a 'conscience
clause' in law for religiously motivated breaches of anti-discrimination
law may set an interesting precedent for the future.
The case erupted when in 2008, B&B owners Peter and
Hazelmary Bull accepted a booking for a double room from Steven Preddy,
believing him to be coming with his wife. When Preddy arrived at the
Chymorvah House in Cornwall, to the surprise of the religious hoteliers,
he was instead accompanied by his gay partner Martyn Hall.
The proprietors made it clear they could not give Preddy
and Hall a double room due to religious reasons and proceeded to turn
them away. Subsequently, the gay couple was awarded £3,600 in
compensation, after court proceedings which found the Bulls to be in
breach of anti-discrimination law.